NinA AI Agency

Knowledge · choosing an AI partner

Choosing an AI agency: twelve questions that show the difference

Since 2023, almost every agency calls itself an AI agency. On their websites they look alike. In the first meeting they don't, if you ask the right questions. Here are the four types of providers, twelve questions with what a good answer is, and the red flags. Also about us: we tell you when we're not a fit.

  • By Olaf Lemmens
  • Updated 27 October 2026
  • Including when we're not a fit
  1. InShortlist of threePreferably different types of providers
  2. HumanFirst meetingWith the twelve questions below
  3. HumanCall a referenceA client who is a year further along
  4. AISmall first stepA workshop or a scan with a number
  5. DoneDecisionBased on numbers, not on a demo

Choose on evidence, not on promises

Why is choosing an AI agency so hard?

Because everyone says the same thing. Every agency promises "AI that really works", has logos on its site and shows an impressive demo. But a demo isn't proof. A demo runs on clean sample data, without your ERP, without exceptions and without a colleague saying: that's not how we do it here.

On top of that, AI work consists of three very different crafts: teaching people to work with AI, deciding where AI delivers value, and actually building it and keeping it running. Most providers are good at one of the three. That's not a problem, as long as you know which one you need.

So the question isn't "who is the best AI agency?", but: who fits what we need now, and who will still be around in a year?

Twelve questions for the first meeting

Take these questions with you. Pay less attention to the answer itself than to how quickly and concretely it comes.

  1. 01Where do you start when you come in to work with us? A good answer is about your work and processes, not about a tool or a model.
  2. 02How do you calculate what it delivers? You want to hear a method: time per step, number of people, frequency, and a scenario that's cautious enough. Not a percentage from a report.
  3. 03What do you do if it doesn't pay off? An honest agency says it won't start then, or recommends something smaller.
  4. 04Do you build yourselves, or do you outsource that? Advice without builders often leads to a fine plan that nobody carries out. Builders without advice sometimes build the wrong thing.
  5. 05Can I call a client who has been working with you for a year? A reference from after go-live says more than a case on the website.
  6. 06Who approves the AI's work? The answer should be about people: where is the check, and who decides on exceptions?
  7. 07Where is our data stored, and which model do you use? You want to hear: in the EU, with a business data processing agreement, and a model that doesn't train on your data.
  8. 08Who owns what you build? Code, data and documentation should be yours. Also ask how long it takes to leave.
  9. 09Who keeps it running after delivery? Models change, and so do systems. Without management it won't work anymore in six months.
  10. 10How do you bring our team along? Most resistance is in people, not in software. Training and guidance belong in the plan.
  11. 11What does it cost, and where does the usage come in? You want a fixed price or a clear hourly rate, plus an honest picture of licenses, AI usage and hosting.
  12. 12What's a small first step? A good provider can start without you signing a big project straight away.

Red flags in the first meeting

  • The solution is fixed before the process has been discussed. "You need a chatbot", in the first ten minutes.
  • Savings without a calculation. "This saves 70 percent" without knowing how long the work takes now.
  • Fully autonomous as the default. Most tasks need a human who checks. Anyone who waves that away hasn't put much live yet.
  • No answer to the data question. Or: "the tool takes care of that".
  • Only pilots in the portfolio. A pilot is easy. Something that's still running a year later is the real work.
  • Lock-in. Code that only runs on their platform, or no documentation when you leave.
  • Everyone in the meeting is from sales. Ask whether a developer or consultant can join the next meeting.

What does an AI agency cost?

That depends on what you buy: knowledge, advice or building. So don't just compare the hourly rate, but also what happens after delivery. A cheap build without management often turns out expensive.

For comparison, our own prices, excluding VAT: a talk costs € 2,450, a workshop € 4,500 per half day, the AI Quick Scan € 6,000 one-off and the AI Partnership € 4,500, € 7,500 or € 12,000 a month, for a minimum of twelve months. A single rate of € 150 an hour for consulting and development. Everything at a glance, including the costs of licenses and usage, is on what does AI cost.

When NinA isn't a fit

Fair is fair. We're not a fit for everyone.

  • You want one app built and then carry on yourself. We only build within a partnership, because we want it to keep working. For a one-off assignment, a software agency is a better fit.
  • You're only looking for a tool to buy. Then you'll get more out of a good vendor and AI training for your team.
  • The business case doesn't clear the bar. Our guarantee is at least 2x back in the first year. If the expected scenario doesn't reach that, we don't start a partnership. A workshop is then often the better first step.

We are a fit if you want to go beyond experimenting, want to bring your team along and are looking for a permanent partner who advises, builds and then keeps it running. How we work is explained in the APO method.

Four types of providers

Who does what?

A rough classification. Each type has its place; what matters is what you need now.

Freelance AI consultantLarge consultancy firmSoftware or IT agencyAI agency with its own builders
Strong atQuick advice, direct contactStrategy and large programsBuilding to specificationAdvice, building and training in one team
Decides where AI delivers value✓✓·✓
Builds itselfSometimesOften outsourced✓✓
Trains and guides your teamSometimesSometimes·✓
Keeps it running·Sometimes✓✓
Fits whenYou want to sharpen one questionIt's an organization-wide programYou know exactly what you want builtYou want to go from plan to working AI, and beyond

Swipe sideways to see all columns →

A broad classification, not a judgment of individual providers.

Questions

Questions about choosing an AI agency

What does an AI agency do?

An AI agency helps organizations use AI in their work. That can be knowledge (talks, workshops and training), advice (deciding where AI delivers value and making a plan) or building (AI agents and automations connected to existing systems). Some agencies do one of the three, others all three.

What should I look for when choosing an AI agency?

Five things: does it start with your processes instead of a tool, can it calculate the return, does it build itself, is there a plan for management after delivery, and are the code and data yours. On top of that, call a reference who has been working with the agency for a year.

What's the difference between an AI consultant and an AI agency?

An AI consultant advises: where AI fits, what it delivers, in what order. An AI agency can also build and manage. Advice without builders often leads to a plan that gathers dust; building without advice leads to the wrong solution.

How big should an AI agency be?

Big enough to cover illness, holidays and people leaving, and to combine advice, building and management. Ask how many developers are in-house and who will be working on your project.

Does an AI agency need to be certified?

A certificate such as ISO 27001 says something about how an agency handles information security. In any case, ask where your data is stored, which model is used and whether there's a data processing agreement. NinA works to ISO 27001 and NEN 7510; certification is in preparation.

What's a good first step with a new AI agency?

Something small with a clear outcome. A workshop shows how an agency works with your team. A scan with a business case shows whether it can do the numbers. At NinA, that's the AI Quick Scan: one day on site, and within a week a baseline measurement, a business case per opportunity and a roadmap.

Ask us the twelve questions

In a fifteen-minute intro call. You get an answer from a human, and if we're not a fit, we'll say so.

  1. 01

    Intro call

    Fifteen minutes, no strings. Where does work get stuck and what do you want to achieve?

  2. 02

    AI Quick Scan

    One day on site. Within a week, a business case and a roadmap.

  3. 03

    AI Partnership

    A dedicated team that builds, trains and shows what it delivers every month.

160+ organizations · Sessions rated 9.3 · Based in Amsterdam